One thing we are not short of in Liverpool is Italian food, in various forms from the long standing and rather dated Casa Italia to the swanky Il Forno and San Carlo. Various versions of chain restaurants do pizza in a hurry or cheap Italian eats, however the independent Italian clubs or Tribeca top anything their mass market competitors serve up. Thus when another established chain opens up not only does it have to offer equal quality and value it would have to provide something special to attract me away from my favoured independents.
I know, I know, that’s a bit of a poor way to start a review, to paraphrase myself, if it’s not amazing food and cheap prices I’m not going. Does it have any chance? Honestly, probably not. Its more of a principal based decision, I choose to go to independents because usually they are better, but even if they only equal what is on offer in the well known chains, I prefer to spend my money there than in a big national organisation.
So is the Carluccio’s food superb? No. Are Carluccio’s prices ridiculously cheap? No. Our food was fine on my one visit, starters were a decent bruschetta and reasonable liver pate, a main of anchovy penne with tomato sauce and chilli was a little to hot and lacked any noticeable anchovy. A chicken Milanese, was an escallop breadcrumbed and fried, crunchy and crisp outer layer was good but the inside was over cooked and dry. Puddings followed a similar theme, they were OK, a nice fruit tart and good chocolate mouse. This was all fairly cheap as we had the fixed price menu, all this for £12.70 was good but only really matches the many other fixed price menus about town.
So to sum up, in my opinion, if I wanted Italian food in Liverpool, I would head elsewhere, one of several city centre independents would be my choice. That is not to say the food is bad, its not, it was decent and probably equal to some other places in town. If you want to support independents, as I do, then really I wouldn’t bother with Carluccio’s, however, if you don’t and you’re in town it’s not a bad place to go.



















